In the first article on tire tests, we present the results of tests by the "Za rulem" publication, which conducted them at the AvtoVAZ testing ground. One of the most popular tire sizes, 185/60R14, was chosen for the test. The geography of manufacturing plants is vast, from the UK to the Philippines, from Portugal to Russia. This list also includes a Ukrainian tire.
1. Nokian Hakka Green / 959 points
Pros
Excellent braking properties on dry and wet asphalt
Excellent road holding at high speed
Extreme maneuvers can be performed at high speed on both dry and wet asphalt
Brake better than others on wet asphalt
Low noise level
Cons
Somewhat stiff
Summary: Ideal outside the city on paved roads, economical.
2. Continental ContiPremiumContact 5 / 943 points
Pros
Minimal braking distance on wet and dry asphalt
Excellent road holding at high speed
Extreme maneuvers can be performed at high speed, but slightly inferior to Nokian in this component
Low noise level on good road surfaces
Cons
Feel any road irregularities
Summary: Strengths will be especially evident outside the city on good asphalt roads, economical.
3. Pirelli Cinturato P1 / 925 points
Pros
Good braking properties on dry asphalt
Excellent road holding at high speed on dry and wet asphalt
Can perform sharp lane changes at high speed on dry roads
Low noise level on good road surfaces
Economical both outside the city and in the city
Cons
Average braking distance on wet roads
Feel any road irregularities
Summary: Good on suburban highways with good surfaces, economical.
4. Hankook Kinergy eco / 916 points
Pros
Good braking properties on dry asphalt
On wet roads, braking performance is close to the test leaders
Hold the road well, but having a wide "zero", when changing lanes, they respond to steering with a delay
The car performs lane change maneuvers excellently on wet roads. In this indicator, Hankook is on par with the leaders
Silent and soft on good surfaces
Cons
Directional stability could be better
Summary: They perform well in the city and outside the city on roads with quality surfaces.
5. Nordman SX / 915 points
Pros
Good braking on dry and wet asphalt
Good directional stability, however, there are delays when changing lanes and a vague "zero"
Silent and quite soft
Cons
There is a slight tendency to skid
On a "cut-up" road, the car vibrates
Summary: They perform well in the city and outside the city on paved roads.
6. Bridgestone MY-02 Sporty Style / 893 points
Pros
Good braking properties on dry asphalt
Low noise level
Cons
Braking on wet asphalt could be more effective
At high speed, poor directional stability, unclear "zero"
When performing extreme maneuvers on dry roads, speed has to be limited due to skidding
Low ride comfort
Summary: For good roads.
7. Yokohama C.drive2 / 891 points
Pros
Hold the course clearly at high speed, but lane change maneuver is hindered by a wide "zero" and delayed response to steering
Silence and comfort on roads of any quality
Economical
Cons
During sharp maneuvers on dry or wet asphalt, speed is limited by low feedback
Tendency to skid
Average speed on wet roads
Summary: Tires for lovers of comfort and fuel economy.
8. Amtel Planet T-301 / 887 points
Pros
Good steering response
Maneuvering is possible at high speed. Speed is limited by sharp skidding, but the car can be straightened with a quick reaction. Good steering feedback will help
The same is typical for wet roads
Cons
Poor braking results on wet and dry asphalt
Noisy
Stiff
Increased fuel consumption on suburban roads
Summary: Good outside the city, but not on dirt roads.
9. Michelin Energy XM2 82T / 879 points
Pros
Quiet and soft
Economical
Cons
Poor test results on wet and dry asphalt
At high speed, the car is unstable, poor steering response and wide "zero"
Prone to skidding on dry roads when changing lanes
Even more skidding on slippery roads
Summary: For lovers of leisurely driving.
10. Cordiant Sport 2 (PS-501) / 872 points
Pros
Brake satisfactorily on wet asphalt
Cons
Braking on dry roads is unsatisfactory
Unclear "zero", delayed reactions, at high speeds constant course correction is required
Extreme maneuvering on dry roads is difficult. Speed is limited by the danger of deep skidding
Noisy and stiff
Increased fuel consumption
Summary: For driving in city traffic jams.
11. Contyre Megapolis / 828 points
Pros
Quiet
Cons
Braking is unsatisfactory, the difference with the leader is 5.8 m.
Lack of "steering feel" on wet roads, speed is limited by deep skidding
Extreme maneuvers are possible at a noticeably lower speed than others
Do not hold the course quite clearly on a straight line
Stiff
Increased fuel consumption
Summary: Despite the last place, Ukrainian tires are quite suitable "for leisurely driving". True, it is necessary to carefully monitor the distance.
Summary table of test results:
Earlier, AvtoPortal wrote about how tire rolling resistance affects fuel consumption and what aquaplaning is.